Flock and Cyble Inc. Weaponize "Cybercrime" Takedowns to Silence Critics

(haveibeenflocked.com)

215 points | by _a9 3 hours ago

11 comments

  • greyface- 1 hour ago
    If Flock truly believed that the domain name infringes on their trademark, they would file an ICANN UDRP complaint instead of Cloudflare and Hetzner abuse reports.

    But they don't, because the former would require them to perjure themselves, and the latter just requires them to lie to a hosting company.

    • CalChris 1 hour ago
      I wonder if Flock + Cyble can be sued for fraud. There are 5 elements in a fraud:

        Misrepresentation of Fact
        Knowledge of Falsity
        Intent to Induce Reliance 
        Justifiable Reliance 
        Resulting Damages
  • softwaredoug 55 minutes ago
    My city just ended our pilot Flock program. I hope others do the same.

    But I think the real issue with Flock will be private security. Random Home Depot parking lots, etc.

    https://www.29news.com/2025/12/17/charlottesville-ends-flock...

    • rrix2 30 minutes ago
      The local credit union in Eugene had installed Flock cams at the entrances to all their branches. They took em down after only a few of our community members began protests out front a few branches and emailing with the CU's leadership before our city terminated our contract and removed the cams
  • VladVladikoff 25 minutes ago
    > The site’s only input fields accept license plate numbers (which are hashed client-side before transmission and cannot be harvested)

    License plates are trivially short, hashing them accomplishes no additional level of privacy if the hashes could be bruted in seconds on an antique GPU.

    • hibf 13 minutes ago
      Technically true. Flock could present an unfounded argument that I might be brute-forcing my own security and privacy measures.

      I think it'd sound pretty dumb.

  • _a9 3 hours ago
    Part 2: Flock and Cyble Inc. Continue to File False Notices

    https://haveibeenflocked.com/news/cyble-part2

  • defrost 2 hours ago
    Related: Flock Said It Does Not Use Dark Web Data. Code Analysis Tells a Different Story - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46341674
  • Kim_Bruning 29 minutes ago
    If these folks get in trouble, they might try hosting with Freedom.nl . It's +/- the old xs4all crew, and they might be in for some more fun in the 21st century.
  • cosmicgadget 1 hour ago
    > With the new Divinity game in the works, I decided to do a run as Gale in BG3.

    I don't support this decision but I respect it.

    Curious what the Cloudflare HNers have to say about this debacle.

    • hibf 23 minutes ago
      Can't be less than what support has had to say up until now.
  • CamperBob2 2 hours ago
    This is a Y Combinator company? https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/flock-safety

    dang/tomhow, does Y Combinator have a code of ethics that comes into play when one of your funding recipients does something unethical and/or illegal like this?

    • avaer 2 hours ago
      One long-standing code is that they moderate YC companies less on HN, allowing criticisms like yours to stand: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34320816

      To HN's credit I haven't seen this rule violated.

      For example I wouldn't have known it was a YC company if not for your comment.

    • edm0nd 2 hours ago
      yeah their code of ethics is to laugh all the way to the bank and be untouchable. nothing will happen to them from YC.
    • mmooss 57 minutes ago
      Are dang and tomhow involved at all in YC member ethics? I expect they know about ethical behavior on HN.
    • venturecruelty 47 minutes ago
      First time?
    • sergiotapia 1 hour ago
      So these are the scumbags putting cameras in front of schools and sending tickets to people on Sundays. Thank you for making peoples lives materially WORSE.
      • sneak 1 hour ago
        Speeding tickets are not related in any way to why Flock (YC S17)* is bad.

        * how I will now always refer to them

  • tamimio 2 hours ago
    Remember when Zuck called his fellow students at harvard who used facebook “Dumb fucks”? The US is accelerating into techno-authoritarianism, and all of these tech companies adopted “companies over countries” motto since the start, it’s not a surprise now.
    • sneak 1 hour ago
      it’s important to contextualize that quote: he called them dumbfucks specifically because they trusted him with their data.
      • Aeglaecia 1 hour ago
        it is fairly evident that contextualisation is paramount in objectively assessing a situation ... in the context of having god like power over billions , it seems entirely moot to debate the merits of why such a god like individual would label his subjects as idiots ...
      • tamimio 57 minutes ago
        The context is given, it’s all about users’ data. facebook, google, plantir, flock, you name it, the end goal is to harvest data as much as possible to sell it, profile the individuals, manipulate the public opinion (facebook did a mood-manipulation “experiment” back in 2012, you can only imagine now in the era of social media dependency and AI), invade people’s privacy, among many other things. Now add to that mix a mandatory digital ID, and let’s hear what these CEOs will call the public behind closed doors, I’m sure it’s worse than “dumb fucks”. Fun fact: Zuck early days business card printed with “I’M THE CEO, BITCH.”
    • bongodongobob 1 hour ago
      In the sense that the US has been anti-intellectualist for decades, I'm kind of ok with it. All the kids who fucked around in school and picked on the nerds for just existing are kind of getting their comeuppance. It's definitely cut off your nose to spite your face type shit, but does give me a little bit of joy. "You stuffed me in a locker and destroyed my social life because I read a book at lunch. I'm going to automate your job away and help billionaires make sure you'll never rise out of poverty."
      • CamperBob2 55 minutes ago
        All the kids who fucked around in school and picked on the nerds for just existing are running the government. Not sure this is the win you're painting it as?
      • Terr_ 59 minutes ago
        I don't think "the nerds" are really dishing out much comeuppance here.

        Professionally, they're marginalized by finance-bros, who actually decide what gets built and which morals get followed. Privately, everything you might want to repair or tweak or invent is still getting locked down or patented or criminalized.

      • venturecruelty 44 minutes ago
        How much does food and electricity cost you (if the electricity is even on for you at all)? Also, uh, this isn't high school anymore, and the "nerds vs. jocks" framing says a lot more about your own internal state than it does about the state of the world, which is being run into the ground by wealthy oligarchs. If you have bad high school memories to process, that can be done elsewhere.
  • citizenkeen 1 hour ago
    Is this not libel?
    • hibf 21 minutes ago
      They don't actually allege anything. They add in the keywords without going so far as to say "this website is doing X." It's enough to trip the keyword filters at Cloudflare and other hosting providers and reverse the burden of proof.
    • dawnerd 57 minutes ago
      Problem is they have way more money to fight and that’s basically their whole playbook. I was caught up in a fraudulent libel claim that had to settle* back in the Twitter days. When those companies want to come after you, it’s really hard to fight back.

      * no money was exchanged just some guarantees to not disclose their client and remove tweets.

  • therobots927 2 hours ago
    Absolutely unacceptable behavior. Wild that Americans are so distracted by pointless social issues that they haven’t even realized the ruling elite are treating them like cattle. Absolutely pathetic.
    • westmeal 1 hour ago
      The pointless social issues are manufactured specifically in order to distract Americans from the fact they are being treated like cattle.
      • chii 1 hour ago
        > are manufactured specifically

        the fact that these majority do accept the distraction points to lack of intelligence and discipline in critical thinking and future planning. The populous has half the blame - not just those who do these manufacturing of distractions.

      • anjel 1 hour ago
        Cattle is as Cattle does
      • ares623 1 hour ago
        And they/we absolutely love the distraction
        • therobots927 1 hour ago
          Because our educational system has been dismantled
          • throwaway0xT 22 minutes ago
            Cloudflare outage on Dec. 5 on remote servers were /user/ parsing errors in HTTP.

            Flock does this well in terms of bios spinlock releases, whereas a secure measure is stress-testing network traffic.

    • JumpCrisscross 1 hour ago
      > Wild that Americans are so distracted

      There is a tonne of civic action against Flock, specifically, in the works, in many cases with successful results.

    • 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 50 minutes ago
      Like what?
    • voidfunc 1 hour ago
      America is huge and there's a lot of exceptionally stupid people especially in the South and Midwest.

      Not much I can do about that over here in the coastal Northeast.

      • b00ty4breakfast 8 minutes ago
        "us smarties would never fall for such obvious bread and circus. not like those silly dumdums what live in {region}!"

        said without an ounce irony as the proverbial rug is yanked right out from under your feet

      • hermannj314 24 minutes ago
        I was offended and then I defined "exceptionally stupid" a few ways and all the statistics support this claim.

        I'm still offended though.

        Fucking a lot of smart people in Mass., Vermont, Conn., New York, Maryland, DC.